按Enter到主內容區
:::

性侵害犯罪之國際法規範<P>THE CRIME OF RAPE UNDER INTERNATIONAL LAW.

  • 發布日期:
  • 最後更新日期:109-05-13
  • 資料點閱次數:145
Susan Brownmiller曾言:「女性權利之歷史沿革,如同國家發展軌跡一般緩慢而曲折」,探究女性權利之發展,始終難脫離父權結構與公私二元。而於國際法領域,人權規範雖於二戰後蓬勃發展,惟女性人權依然受到漠視,其中,尤以性侵害犯罪之規範最為不足。近幾年來,隨著武裝衝突頻繁發生,女性人權之危急情勢日益升高,戰時下之性侵,往往伴隨著酷刑及死亡之風險,許多女性更因而染上難以治癒之性病,其亦使國際法之態度轉為積極,除聯合國陸續透過安理會決議表達關注與譴責外,更先後設立前南斯拉夫及盧安達國際刑事法庭,透過兩法院之解釋,性侵害犯罪已脫離家庭權利及婦女榮譽尊嚴之論述,其更肯定戰時性侵將可能構成酷刑、違反人道罪、戰爭罪及種族滅絕罪。另於2002年,國際社會通過羅馬規約,將戰時性侵之禁止規範予以明文,堪為一大進步。此外,於國際人權法領域,透過聯合國禁止酷刑委員會、CEDAW委員會及區域性人權法院之實踐,性侵害犯罪已和酷刑、私生活保障和禁止歧視原則相連結,而被視為相當嚴重之犯罪,性侵害犯罪已構成對人權之違反,至為灼然。 本文以案例分析為主,輔以歷史研究法與女性主義法學方法,首先探究性侵害犯罪之歷史沿革,從其規範之起源為出發點,並分別以歷史與文化角度觀之,其發現性侵害犯罪之規範,和女性社會地位存在相當緊密之關聯。另國際社會之性侵害犯罪,雖深受內國法影響頗深,惟仍具有其特殊性,其中更以戰時之性侵最為特殊,故亦將予以介紹。於國際法之實體規範部分,本文除簡單介紹相關條約內容外,亦將透過前南斯拉夫國際刑事法庭、盧安達國際刑事法庭、國際刑事法院、聯合國酷刑委員會、人權事務委員會、CEDAW委員會、美洲人權法院及歐洲人權法院之判決,歸納並分析國際法對性侵害犯罪之法理與見解,並依此探究國家於本議題所應負之國家義務與責任。本文並發現,國際法對於性侵害犯罪成立國際罪刑、酷刑、私生活侵犯及歧視,已逐漸形成一致性之見解,其標準並逐漸具體化,此外,國家於此議題尤應負其適當性注意義務與積極義務,性犯罪之國際法規範始得以落實。本文終章將歸納全文之研究結果,並分別就國際社會與我國之實踐提出建議。

"The historic development of the rights of women, like the development of nations, proceeded at an uneven pace” said Susan Brownmiller (Susan Brownmiller, Against our Will, p.34, 1993). From the feminist perspective, patriarchy and public/private dichotomy are still major issues for the women’s rights movement. In the field of public international law, the Second World War marked a turning point in the development of human rights law; however, it is a tragic fact that the human rights of women are still being disregarded in many places. After 1990, the number of armed conflicts in the world has increased. The rape cases committed in armed conflicts has always accompanied by the risk of torture, AIDS and death, and the victims often are those who are most vulnerable. The United Nations has taken progressive steps to end impunity for rape; their substantial efforts have ranged from condemnation by the UN Security Council resolution to the judicial work of the ad hoc tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda. These courts all confirmed that rape cases in war did amount to the crime of torture, crimes against humanity, war crimes and genocide, with not only national but also international implications. The International Criminal Court was officially established in 2002 in accordance with the Rome Statute. The Rome Statute stipulates that rape could constitute a war crime and crime against humanity. Within the field of international human rights law, the prohibition of rape was recently acted upon through the practice of United Nations Committee against Torture, CEDAW Committee and the regional human rights court.

From their points of view, rape could be linked to torture, the protection of private life and non-discrimination principle, and can be regarded as a very serious violation of human rights. This thesis focuses on the case study on the prohibition of rape under international law, comparing the areas of international humanitarian law, international criminal law, and human rights law. The first chapter explores the origins of peacetime and wartime rape cases, both from the perspectives of culture and history. As to substantial discourses, this study goes through the decisions of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, the International Criminal Court, the UN Committee against Torture, the Human Rights Committee, CEDAW Committee, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, and the European Court of Human Rights. The study then goes on to summarize and analyze the jurisprudence and principles of international law concerning the crime of rape, the due diligence and positive obligations of State. Under the due diligence obligations, States have a duty to take assertive action to prevent and protect women from being raped, punish perpetuators and compensate victims. The final chapter summarizes the results of the study, and makes recommendations for international and Taiwan's law practitioners.

資料來源:http://handle.ncl.edu.tw/11296/ndltd/11240545838361281352

回頁首