按Enter到主內容區
:::

性侵害加害人之痛覺同理心與道德判斷之探究

  • 發布日期:
  • 最後更新日期:109-05-13
  • 資料點閱次數:119
病態人格是一種以情感缺陷及道德缺失為核心特質的發展疾患。研究證據亦顯示情感上的缺陷與腦部區域的異常有關。在檢閱相關文獻後,研究者認為病態人格之腦部異常區域,與同理心、道德判斷以及性行為背後之神經機制似乎有重疊之處。因此,本研究目的旨在探討病態人格之性侵害加害人在痛覺同理心與道德判斷之表現,是否與非病態人格之性侵害加害人及一般犯罪者存在差異。 本研究對象選取於臺北監獄與嘉義監獄,先以病態人格檢索表(Psychopathy Checklist- Revised, PCL-R)篩選病態人格之性侵害加害人(n = 10),並依據受試者年齡與教育程度選取配對的非病態人格之性侵害加害人(n = 10)與控制組(n = 10),進行痛覺同理心與道德判斷實驗。 研究結果顯示,病態人格之性侵害加害人在觀看痛覺刺激時,採取自己觀點(self-perspective)與他人觀點(others-perspective)所做出之情緒評價皆為負向的,且情緒強度並無差異。亦即,病態人格之性侵害加害人具備觀點取替(perspective-taking)之認知能力,能夠分辨他人負向情感線索。研究者推測病態人格之性侵害加害人的同理心缺陷,可能來自於對他人痛苦無法產生情感反應(affective responsiveness)。而在道德判斷實驗結果上,病態人格之性侵害加害人、非病態人格之性侵害加害人與一般犯罪者並無差異。推測病態人格之性侵害加害人亦具備分辨行為對與錯之能力,但他們可能對於其行為對被害人所造成的影響並不在乎。根據本研究發現,研究者對未來政策及研究方向提出建議。

Psychopathy is one kind of developmental disorder characterized by affective deficits and a lack of morality. Research has shown that affective deficits were associated with the abnormal areas of the brain. Psychopaths may have deficit in empathy, moral judgment, and sexual behaviors. Therefore, the aim of this study was to examine the ability of pain empathy and moral judgment among psychopath sex offenders, non-psychopath sex offenders, and non-psychopath offenders. Psychopathy Checklist-Revised (PCL-R) was used to screen participants from Taipei Prison and Chiayi Prison in Taiwan. The experimental group consisted of 10 psychopath sex offenders, 10 Non-psychopath sex offenders and 10 non-psychopath offenders. They were required to participate in the pain empathy and moral judgment tasks. Results showed that the three group did not have significant differences in discriminating the emotional valences of self-perspective from others-perspective. I also found that they assessed the emotional intensity of the two perspectives similarly. Namely, perspective-taking abilities were possessed by psychopath sex offenders, implying that they were able to recognize others’ negative affective clues. However, I speculated that the lack of empathy of psychopathic sex offenders may be attributed to their inability to produce affective responsiveness. The data of moral judgment showed that there were no differences in the three groups.I suggested that psychopath sex offenders may distinguish right from wrong, yet they did not pay attention to the adverse impacts arising from their behaviors on the victims. Based on the results, implications for policy and future research are proposed.

資料來源:http://handle.ncl.edu.tw/11296/ndltd/24252828514881168082

回頁首